Two Texas Mysteries

Two Texas Mysteries

Take a good look at these photos from Peggy Batchelor Hamlett. I can date them, but I'm still working on identifying the symbolism on the men's shirts shirts. Pictorial Evidence: The design of the mat for the above image suggests it was taken in the 1860s...

092109img041 (5).jpg

Take a good look at these photos from Peggy Batchelor Hamlett. I can date them, but I’m still working on identifying the symbolism on the men’s shirts shirts.

Pictorial Evidence:

  • The design of the mat for the above image suggests it was taken in the 1860s.
  • The image is a tintype, which isn’t unusual for the time period.
  • The man’s beard in the photo above is a style called a Greeley, after newspaper publisher Horace Greeley. In the image below, the man wears an imperial-style beard.
  • Both men’s shirts are in the style of a collarless work shirt with a double-buttoned small band around the neck.
  • The eight pointed stars on shirt of the man above and the design down the button placket are very interesting. The eight-pointed star is called the Star of Redemption, and is associated with baptisms.

Peggy and I are trying to determine if this image represents her ancestor Dr. Francis Marion Montgomery, of Tyler, Texas, who was born c. 1830. He was a devout Methodist and became a circuit minister.

Montgomery could be the man in the image above, but there’s one problem—the second image, below. Who is this man, and do the shirts signify that the two pictures are related somehow?

092109img038 (3).jpg

This image made me start from scratch. I’ve seen work shirts like these from the 1860s, but frankly, I haven’t seen this design before. In the second photo, the design looks like either a tree of life or the flame of life.

Are these fraternal society photos? I don’t think so. I consulted with Rhonda McClure of the New England Historic Genealogical Society, and we agreed the markings are unusual, but couldn’t find a fraternal match. David Lintz of the Improved Order of Red Men is taking a look at the images to see if he recognizes their significance.

A couple of folks at the Smith County Historical Society in Tyler, Texas, are working on this problem, too. They have a large photo archive, so my hope is that someone there will have an “aha!” moment. They’re considering Civil War Uniforms or volunteer firemen.

Could the shirts be traditional attire from another country? Peggy’s family had been in the country for a while when these images were taken.

Could the pictures show Montgomery and a colleague who traveled with him on the circuit? I contacted the United Methodist Archives at Drew University, but they couldn’t identify the star or the other design as part of their symbolism.

Could these be people who aren’t in Peggy’s family? Anything is possible.

At this point I’m waiting to hear back from a few folks … I’ll keep you posted. If you have any ideas, contact me.

Related Products


Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>


  1. Candace Fountoulakis

    Something about the men and their &quot;fancy&quot; shirts reminds me of a circus. Still searching for clues to the mystery couple I sent you this summer in the needlework &quot;Father Mother&quot; mat. Now seems they may actually be Francis Julius Lemoyne Newburn (named for Francis Julius Lemoyne of Washington, PA, who was the delivering doctor) and wife, probably wife #1 Priscilla Parsons (wife #2 was Mary Elizabeth Hull, whom he married in 1869). Hoping the Newburn, Hull or Brinkworths will identify this photo for me from their collections since they might have a copy of the same photo. Thanks so much, have read your book on preserving your family photos and am in the process of protecting them in the right sort of box with the protective sleeves and paper.

    • I am a direct descendant of Francis Julius Lemoyne Newburn. My dad came across your comment. I would love to see the pic and hear how you came across it. I realize that you posted this comment almost a decade ago, but maybe you will see this. Feel free to find me on facebook under Becci Newburn