Dear Ms. City-Cousin,
I have good news and bad news regarding your request that I look for your ancestor in the 1905 city directory of our town on Ancestry.com.
The bad news is that Ancestry does not have the 1905 city directory of our town, even though it has several other years.
The good news is that we have a copy of that directory, along with more than 100 years of city directories for our town, as well as several years of county and farm directories.
Attached to this email is a scan of the title page, along with the page listing your ancestor and everyone else with that surname.
Your Genealogy Librarian
Genealogy research in city directories
Ancestry.com has a huge collection of digitized city directories. Its collection “U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995” has more than 1.5 billion records. (It’s also the third most-popular collection on the site, behind Public Member Trees and the 1940 federal census.)
Perhaps because of the size of the collection, many people think that if the directory isn’t on Ancestry.com, it doesn’t exist. Yes, Ancestry’s collection is enormous, but it doesn’t have everything.
Don’t worry! There are lots of places to look for the directories you need—and those listed below are free.
Where to look for old city directories that list your ancestors
1. The public library in the city or county of interest. Public libraries often collect directories for their own city and county. Start with their online catalogs. However, many libraries don’t list each year of the directory they hold. The catalog might list only the earliest year, or give a range of years with no indication of missing volumes. If you don’t find what you’re looking for in the catalog, contact the library. (Bonus: Some libraries have digitized directories for their area. I recently discovered several Columbus city directories on the website of the Columbus Metropolitan Library.)
2. MyHeritage. More specifically, search the free Compilation of Published Sources on MyHeritage, which contains a variety of types of books in addition to city directories.
3. Internet Archive. Besides hosting the Wayback Machine, Internet Archive has digitized millions of items, including city and county directories. To find them, begin with a basic search of city directory or county directory (For example, Indianapolis city directory or Nassau county directory.)
4. Google Books. Use the same search strategy that you would on Internet Archive. However, be aware that some results may only be a snippet or preview of the full directory.
5. Online Historical Directories Website. This website has links to hundreds of online directories. Also check out Linkpendium and Cyndi’s List (note that some of the links on these sites lead to fee-based resources).
6. WorldCat. If the local public library doesn’t have the directory you need and you can’t find it digitized online, look it up in WorldCat to see what other libraries have it.
Though Ancestry.com’s collection of city directories is massive, it doesn’t include all of the ones that have been published. The local public library and other websites can help you fill in the gaps.