We tested budget models from three top scanner manufacturers, holding them up to both genealogy and graphic-design standards. The verdict: Whatever your skill level or scanning tasks, you can find a cheap flatbed that fits the bill.
HP Scanjet 2200c
Hewlett-Packard is known for beginner-friendly computer products, and the Scanjet 2200c doesn’t disappoint. It’s great for novices who want a basic scanner they can master without much effort.
As long as you’re a PC-using novice, that is. This $79 USB scanner works solely with Windows (98 or higher). You also need a 90MHz processor, 32MB RAM and 130MB hard disk space.
The Scanjet 2200c doesn’t come with a user’s guide or detailed instructions — your only guidance is an illustrated poster, but you may not even need that. Everything about the Scanjet 2200c is pretty intuitive, from setup to software.
To scan, just plop your pix on the 8.5×11.7-inch vertical scanning area. (You can remove the lid for bigger or bulkier items.) The scanner has two buttons on the front: Hit Color Copy if you just want to print the photo. Press Scan to launch the HP Precision Scan LTX software and capture the image.
Then edit and share your images with Adobe ActiveShare — the best part of the Scanjet 2200c’s software bundle. This nifty program combines powerful and versatile image-editing capabilities found in Adobe’s other consumer software (PhotoDeluxe, Photoshop Elements — see next page) with loads of Web-sharing options: You can e-mail pix, upload images to a Web site and download shots from a digital camera. Beginners will love ActiveShare’s excellent help features, such as screens explaining each function and how to use it. The scanner also comes with optical character recognition (OCR) software for turning images of printed pages into text files.
Scans of old photographs came out a tad redder than the originals, but that’s easily corrected with photo-editing software. Overall, this 42-bit, 600 dpi machine produces good-quality images.
Visioneer One Touch 8700 USB
This Windows-driven USB scanner is true to its name — you can perform nearly every scanning function by touching one of the seven buttons on its front panel. Like HP’s Scanjet, the OneTouch 8700 has Scan and Copy/Print buttons, plus five others:
• Custom is a variation of Scan that opens your digitized picture in an image-editing program instead of scanning software.
• E-mail makes a color scan and attaches it to a new e-mail message.
• OCR automatically converts a text scan to a word-processing document using Scan-Soft TextBridge Pro software.
• Fax creates a black-and-white image in your fax application.
• Stop/Cancel halts a scan in progress.
A scanner-button panel lets you perform the same functions from your desktop; just click the scanner icon on your Windows taskbar after you’ve placed an image on the scanning surface. Clicking the icon when the scanner’s empty launches a dialog box where you can configure resolution, image format and default programs for each function. For example, you can set the E-mail button to scan pictures at 72 dpi and send them to America Online. (Keep in mind you can only select actual applications, so this won’t work for Web-based e-mail such as Yahoo! and Hotmail.)
To really take advantage of all these shortcuts, read the manual before diving into digital-imaging projects. The OneTouch 8700 does have a few quirks: For one, you have to align the image correctly on the glass or you’ll get an error when you scan. This isn’t exactly intuitive, because the 8.5×11.7-inch scanning area is horizontal rather than vertical. (It still has a removable lid.)
You can do quite a bit of image editing with the included ScanSoft PaperPort scanning software, but the only image-format options are BMP, JPG and GIF. For images you’ll print, you’ll get better results if you save them as TIF files in MGI PhotoSuite LE, which comes with the scanner, or another dedicated image-editing program.
With 1,200 dpi optical resolution and 48-bit color, this $99 scanner is more advanced — and more complicated — than the Scanjet 2200c. It’s best suited for intermediate users and patient beginners who won’t be overwhelmed by the wealth of functions and features.
Microtek Scan Maker 3800
Microtek’s sleek, $99.99 scanner is the most versatile budget model here: It’s PC- and Mac-friendly, has a great software package — featuring Adobe image-editing programs — and comes with a gizmo that enables you to scan slides and negatives.
You can use the ScanMaker 3800 with a Pentium-speed PC running at least Windows 98 or with an iMac, G3 or G4. On either platform, you’ll need 64MB RAM (128MB recommended) and a USB port.
This vertically oriented machine has a 8.5×11.7-inch scanning surface, a removable lid and five shortcut buttons. Scan, Copy (for printing), E-mail and OCR operate like the OneTouch 8700. Scan-to-Web is unique: It uploads your scan to an Internet site.
Of all these models, you’ll find the most extensive software package with this 48-bit, 1,200 dpi scanner. Its bundle includes Microtek’s ScanWizard scanning software, ABBYY FineReader OCR and Ulead Photo-Explorer, both an image editor and organizer. Mac users also get Adobe Photoshop LE, while Windows folks get Adobe PhotoDeluxe, as well as Trellix Web, a program that lets you design Web sites without HTML.
ScanMaker 3800’s bonus adapter, the LightLid 35, is an interesting piece of the package. To scan tiny film images with your flatbed, you simply tuck a 35mm slide or strip of film onto the gizmo, set it on the glass and scan as you normally would. But don’t expect miracles. While the LightLid does a passable job of converting film — our test scans needed significant doctoring — it’s not a substitute for an actual film scanner. To get high-quality images from film, you’d need higher optical resolution. So if you have a lot of slides or negatives to digitize, get a true film scanner with at least 2,400 dpi.
Regular flatbed scanning still produces good-quality images, though. As the most advanced of three models, the ScanMaker 3800 would be ideal for family historians who have experience in digital imaging — and the inclusion of Photoshop is a big plus for Mac users.
This utility has several useful tools to complement the program you already use:
• Professional wall charts — Most genealogy programs produce wall charts, but SuperTools offers exceptional flexibility in designing ancestor, descendant, hourglass and fan charts. It adds nice variations on the standard charts, especially a 10-generation fan chart that fits on just 12 sheets of paper.
Like other genealogy software, Super-Tools can print your completed chart on multiple sheets of letter-size paper for you to piece together. But SuperTools also makes it easy to have your chart printed on one large sheet of paper for a much nicer look. Simply submit your file over the Web to Wholly Genes’ printing service. They’ll print it on a single sheet of heavyweight paper using a professional large-format color printer and send it to you in a mailing tube. These attractive charts make ideal gifts or exhibits for a family reunion; prices start at $19.95.
• Powerful file viewing — SuperTools lets you open multiple views of the same data file at one time. You can also view and search data from multiple sources, such as GEDCOM files from other researchers or downloaded from the Internet, and compare it to your own data without merging the files.
• Efficient Web searching — Select one or more people in your file and SuperTools automatically searches for each name on five major genealogy sites: FamilySearch <www.familysearch.org>, Ancestry <Ancestry.com >, Roots Web <www.rootsweb.com>, Gendex <www.gendex.com> and Genealogy Portal <www.genealogyportal.com>.
You can use SuperTools on a 166MHz or faster PC with Windows 95 or higher. Although it requires more hard disk space (51MB) and memory (64MB) than most full-featured genealogy software, response was still slow when editing a 10-generation fan chart on a computer with 192MB RAM. For good performance you’ll want much more than 64MB of memory to edit charts with a lot of names. Note, too, that a picture-heavy chart can take up 40MB or more of disk space, and you may need 200MB or more of free hard disk space to hold temporary files created while the chart is printing.
Add in other features such as multimedia slide shows, historical timelines and relationship and date calculators, and Family Tree SuperTools version 1.1 is an excellent buy. It costs $17.95 to download from <www.whollygenes.com> or $19.95 plus shipping on CD-ROM. (Be advised: Super-Tools is a large file — 26MB — so it could take a long time to download with a dial-up Internet connection.) For more information, contact Wholly Genes at (877) 864-3264.
From the April 2002 issue of Family Tree Magazine