How Genealogy in Germany Compares to US Genealogy

How Genealogy in Germany Compares to US Genealogy

Many US genealogists have German ancestors. But genealogy in Germany—for Germans themselves—often looks different than it does in the United States. German expert James M. Beidler discusses how research in the two countries differs.

Genealogy in Germany has some major differences from genealogy in the United States.

Genealogists use “time and place” to determine what records exist for a particular era and locality of interest. But this tried-and-true principle applies to the present day, too, in a way. Though the “time” is the same, genealogy itself is different based on where you’re researching. Genealogy in Germany, for example, significantly differs from genealogy in the United States in a few interesting ways:

  • The gender balance is reversed in Germany, where a larger percentage of genealogists are men. In the United States, women typically make up a majority of genealogists.
  • Most Americans focus mostly on direct-line ancestry, tracing their ancestors “up the stovepipe” to German-speaking Europe and taking those lines back as far as possible. But Germans take a more collateral approach to family research. Genealogists in Germany want to learn how their ancestors and their families (siblings, cousins, etc.) fared upon leaving for the United States. This likely reflects the direction of the immigration flow.
  • As a whole, German genealogists are less likely to turn to DNA tests than their American counterparts. Many cite Nazi Germany’s misuse of science and genetics. Indeed, genealogy had a bad reputation for decades after World War II. Before and during the war, some Germans compiled pedigrees to “prove” their Aryan descent.

But German and American genealogists share a penchant for coming together for research—Germans even more so, given their stereotypically meticulous nature. Today, the German genealogy society with the largest membership is the Verein für Computergenealogie (in English, the “Society for Computer Genealogy”). In addition, an umbrella group of about 60 societies, called the DAGV, short for Deutsche Arbeitsgemeinschaft Genealogischer Verbände (“German Union of Genealogical Associations”), functions much like the US-based Federation of Genealogical Societies.

Genealogists in Germany have formed many other local and regional groups with varying degrees of formal organization. I’ll discuss some of those German genealogy groups—including how they can help US researchers—in a future blog post.

For more on German genealogy, check out The Family Tree German Genealogy Guide. This comprehensive book shares expert tips for tracing your German roots back to the homeland. Inside, you’ll find detailed guides to German genealogy records, along with easy-to-digest summaries of German history. Even better, the book contains sample letters for requesting records from German archives, plus how to read old German handwriting.

Related Products

1 Comment

Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

ALL COMMENTS

  1. I have done a bit of genealogy and I don’t find that women are more prevalent at it here in the US. I do agree that the Germans are very thorough in their research, I even have a distant cousin in Adelhausen, Germany who has devoted an entire room of his small home to genealogy with a wall covered with his research. Very cool.